Index-Translate vs TranslateGemma: which one to pick?

Index-Translate covers 150 languages under Apache 2.0 and follows glossary and tone instructions. TranslateGemma covers 55 under the Gemma Terms and has far more downloads. We found no independent comparison.

  • Updated

Verdict. Choose by license and by how you give instructions. Index-Translate (2B, 9B and a 35B-A3B preview, 150 languages) is plain Apache 2.0, was built to follow glossary, format and tone instructions, and ships with a 262,144-token context. TranslateGemma (4B, 12B and 27B, 55 evaluated languages) comes from Google under the Gemma Terms of Use, with a strict language-code template, no documented glossary support and a 2K-token input context, but with far more adoption. In the Index team's own tables the 9B is ahead of TranslateGemma-12B on eight of nine columns, by far on instruction following, which TranslateGemma's documented template does not offer. TranslateGemma-12B is slightly ahead on one reference-based instruction benchmark score and has a lower off-target rate on the report's low-resource FLORES test, 1.7% against 4.0%. Google's own evaluation uses other metrics, and we found no independent comparison. Translate a sample of your own text with both.

Specifications

Specifications Index-TranslateTranslateGemma
DeveloperBilibiliGoogle DeepMind
ReleasedSeptember 2026January 15, 2026
Total parameters36B (Index-Translate-35B-A3B (preview, MoE))27.4B (TranslateGemma 27B)
Active parameters3BAll
ArchitectureDenseDense
Context window256K tokens2K tokens
InputText, ImageText, Image
License Apache 2.0 (Permissive) Gemma Terms (Conditional)
Memory for the smallest variant (4-bit)1.44 GB (Index-Translate-2B (GGUF Q4_K_M))2.97 GB (TranslateGemma 4B)

Performance claims come from the developer and have not been independently verified.

Pick Index-Translate if

  • You need plain Apache 2.0, with no use policy to pass on and no gated download.
  • You want to give a glossary, keep JSON, Markdown or placeholders unchanged, or set a tone and genre.
  • You translate languages beyond TranslateGemma's 55 evaluated ones, or inputs longer than its 2K tokens.
  • You want a 2B model with a 1.31 GB GGUF file for a laptop.

Pick TranslateGemma if

  • You want Google's model and the larger community: Hugging Face showed about 1.1 million downloads of the 4B model and about 960,000 of the 12B since release, against about 92,000 for the Index-Translate 9B GGUF.
  • Your pipeline passes ISO language codes and plain text and needs no instructions, so the strict template is a feature.
  • Off-target output matters to you, because TranslateGemma-12B had a lower rate on the Index report's low-resource FLORES test.
  • You accept the Gemma Terms of Use and want a model whose quality Google also checked with human evaluation on WMT25 in 10 language pairs.

Index-Translate · TranslateGemma