Free until you grow: where open licenses draw the line

Thirteen licenses in our catalog end free commercial use at a revenue or user threshold, from US$500,000 to US$50 million. Here is how the lines, the counting and the duties differ.

  • Analysis
  • 3 min read
  • Published

A growing number of open-weights licenses are free for commercial use only up to a point. Thirteen licenses in our catalog set a line, measured in revenue or users, and ask for a separate agreement above it. Our revenue cap entry explains the idea. This article compares where the lines sit, what they count and what happens when you cross them. It is a reading aid, not legal advice.

The lines side by side

License Example model The line Above it
Fish Audio Community Drama 3 US$500,000 a year Separate written license
Krea 2 Community Krea 2 US$1 million, last 12 months Enterprise license
MiniMax-H3-Image MiniMax H3-Image US$1 million a year Written authorization
Datalab Open RAIL-M Chandra OCR 2 US$2 million revenue or raised Commercial use barred
FLUX Kommunity FLUX 3 Image Klein US$5 million a year Commercial license
LTX-2.x Community LTX-2.5 US$10 million a year Paid agreement
LFM Open LFM3 US$10 million a year Not licensed
MiniMax Community MiniMax M3.1 Flash US$20 million a year Written authorization
MiniMax H3 Community MiniMax H3 US$20 million a year Written authorization
ERNIE 5.5 Flash Base ERNIE 5.5 Flash Base US$50 million a year Written authorization
PLaMo Community PLaMo 3 Translate 1 billion yen a year Separate agreement
Tencent Hunyuan HunyuanOCR 100 million monthly users No rights until granted
bilibili Model Use IndexTTS-2.5 100 million users or RMB 1 billion Separate license

What the line counts

Most licenses count you and your affiliates together, so a small subsidiary of a large group does not qualify. LTX says so outright, and LFM follows your whole corporate group. ERNIE counts the revenue of the whole product that uses the model, even if the model is a small part of it. Datalab looks at funding as well as revenue, so a pre-revenue startup that raised more than US$2 million is outside its free tier. Tencent and Bilibili count users instead, with Bilibili also setting a revenue test. The period differs too: Krea uses the last twelve months, PLaMo says revenue or sales, and most others simply say annual revenue.

What happens when you cross it

The licenses differ sharply here. Krea says you must stop commercial use at once and then get an enterprise license. ERNIE wants Baidu’s authorization before you cross. Fish Audio asks you to tell it within 30 days and keeps the community terms for 90 more. PLaMo wants registration before any commercial use and a new license if you stop meeting its conditions. Hunyuan and Bilibili give you no rights until the developer grants a license, and Bilibili may refuse.

What you owe below the line

Free is not unconditional. Several licenses ask for a credit line, such as “Powered by ERNIE” or “Built with PLaMo”, and Krea and PLaMo require their name in what you share. FLUX, Krea and LTX expect content safeguards to stay in place. Seven licenses limit using the model or its outputs to improve other AI models, and four exclude regions such as the EU, the UK and South Korea (see territory restriction). Fish Audio and MiniMax H3-Image also need permission for any hosted service, whatever your revenue.

A ladder for a growing company

Ten of the thirteen lines are in US dollars, and a company passes them one by one. At US$300,000 of yearly revenue you are under all ten. At US$800,000 you have passed Fish Audio’s. At US$3 million you have passed four, adding Krea, MiniMax H3-Image and Datalab, and you are still inside FLUX. At US$15 million you have passed seven, because FLUX, LTX and LFM join them, and at US$60 million you have passed all ten. A model’s license can therefore settle the choice before its quality does.

What to do

Add up your revenue with your affiliates before you pick a model, because the group’s number counts. Treat US$500,000 to US$1 million as a hobby-to-seed line and US$20 million and up as a mid-size line. If you are near a line, ask the developer first. If you cannot predict your growth, choose a permissive license; our commercial-use list shows which models qualify.

Sources

Models in this story

Model Released Parameters Context License Smallest variant needs
Drama 3 Fish Audio 35.9B 3B active – Fish Audio Community 1.0 (Conditional) 25 GB Gaming GPU
Krea 2 Krea 12.8B – Krea 2 Community (Conditional) 41 GB Workstation
MiniMax H3-Image MiniMax 33.1B – MiniMax H3-Image Community (Conditional) 155 GB Big-memory desktop
Chandra OCR 2 Datalab 5.3B 256K OpenRAIL-M (Datalab) (Conditional) 3.66 GB Laptop or phone
FLUX 3 Image Klein Black Forest Labs 5.6B – FLUX Kommunity (Conditional) 8 GB Laptop or phone
LTX-2.5 LTX (Lightricks) 22B – LTX-2.x Community (Conditional) 16 GB Laptop or phone
LFM3 Liquid AI 1.73B – 2.17B 256K LFM Open 1.0 (Conditional) 1.19 GB Laptop or phone
MiniMax M3.1 Flash MiniMax 428B 23B active 1M MiniMax Community (Conditional) 277 GB Big-memory desktop
MiniMax H3 MiniMax 33.1B – MiniMax H3 Community (Conditional) 166 GB Big-memory desktop
ERNIE 5.5 Flash Base Baidu 280B 14B active 1M ERNIE 5.5 Flash Base (Conditional) 193 GB Big-memory desktop
PLaMo 3 Translate Preferred Networks 890M – 31.8B 32K PLaMo Community (Conditional) 0.614 GB Laptop or phone
HunyuanOCR Tencent 1.12B 128K Tencent Hunyuan (Conditional) 0.773 GB Laptop or phone
IndexTTS-2.5 Bilibili 800M – Bilibili Model Use (Conditional) 6 GB Laptop or phone